Triple Screen Trading System by Alexander Elder
⚡ Read this before you open your next trade
The Triple Screen trading system, developed by Dr. Alexander Elder in his 1993 book "Trading for a Living," revolutionized retail trading by systematizing multi-timeframe analysis. The method uses three screens: (1) higher timeframe for trend identification (typically weekly), (2) intermediate timeframe for entry timing with oscillator (daily), and (3) lower timeframe for precise entry execution (intraday). Each screen filters the next, creating a systematic funnel from trend direction to specific entry point. Triple Screen addresses the fatal flaw of many trading strategies: conflicting signals across timeframes. By enforcing trend-following bias from higher timeframe while using mean-reversion tools on intermediate timeframe, the system captures the best of both approaches.
Screen One: Identifying the Market Tide
Screen One establishes direction using higher timeframe. (1) Timeframe selection — if you trade daily, weekly is screen one. If you trade 4H, daily is screen one. Rule: screen one should be 4-5x longer than trade timeframe. (2) Trend indicator — Elder recommends 13-week EMA slope on weekly for stocks, or MACD histogram. Alternative: 26-week EMA, trendlines on weekly chart. (3) Trend interpretation — weekly EMA slope UP = "tide" rising, look for long entries only. Slope DOWN = tide falling, look for short entries only. Flat slope = no trade (avoid chop). (4) MACD histogram approach — weekly MACD histogram rising (green bars growing) = bullish tide. Falling = bearish tide. Zero-line crossovers indicate tide change. (5) Confirmation — combine EMA slope with MACD direction for confidence. Both bullish = strong bullish tide; conflicting = neutral, avoid trading.
Screen one is strict filter: no exceptions. If weekly tide is bullish, only long trades permitted for entire week regardless of daily signals. This discipline prevents the common mistake of shorting uptrends or longing downtrends when intraday noise suggests reversal. Elder's metaphor: as oceanographers distinguish tides (big picture, long timeframe) from waves (short-term movements), traders must align with the tide. Going against the tide, even when waves appear favorable, loses money over time.
Screen Two: Catching the Wave
Screen Two uses intermediate timeframe to identify counter-trend corrections. (1) Purpose — in established trend, find pullbacks for high-R/R entries. Go with tide but buy dips (uptrend) or sell rallies (downtrend). (2) Timeframe — daily chart (if weekly is screen one). Use oscillator to identify oversold (uptrend) or overbought (downtrend) conditions. (3) Oscillator selection — Elder suggests Force Index (2-day EMA), Elder-Ray (bull/bear power), or 13-day Stochastic. Stochastic: < 30 in uptrend = oversold, > 70 in downtrend = overbought. (4) Entry signal generation — in bullish weekly tide: wait for daily Stochastic to fall below 30, then rise back above 30 (exiting oversold) = long signal. Reverse for bearish tide. (5) Alternative: daily MACD histogram — rising from negative territory in uptrend = buy signal; falling from positive territory in downtrend = sell signal.
Key insight: screen two uses oscillator counter to screen one's trend. In uptrend, we BUY WEAKNESS (oversold oscillator). In downtrend, we SELL STRENGTH (overbought oscillator). This contrarian timing within trend alignment produces superior entries. Avoid buying overbought in uptrend (chasing) or selling oversold in downtrend (panic selling). Screen two requires patience — wait for oscillator extremes, often days between setups. Don't force trades when conditions don't align; the market provides regular opportunities for those who wait.
Screen Three: Precise Entry
Screen Three uses intraday timeframe for entry execution. (1) Timeframe — 1H, 30min, or 15min chart (depending on trading style). Provides precision for entry. (2) Entry technique — trailing buy-stop (bullish tide): place buy-stop 1 tick above previous day high. If price rises to that level, triggered entry. If not, cancel at end of day. Reverse for bearish: trailing sell-stop below previous day low. (3) Advantages — enter only when price confirms direction, avoiding false starts. Never enter unless market moves in your favor. (4) Alternative: breakout of intraday consolidation — watch for tight intraday consolidation after screen two signal. Enter on breakout with volume. Precise entry with tight stop. (5) Stop placement — stop inside the consolidation or below entry trigger bar low (for long). ATR-based stop for volatility adjustment. Initial risk typically 1-2% account.
Screen three distinguishes Triple Screen from other multi-timeframe methods. Rather than entering arbitrarily when screens one and two align, wait for price action to validate the thesis. This "market must come to you" approach sharply reduces false entries from delayed oscillator signals or trend reversals between screens. Some traders skip screen three and enter on screen two signals; this costs win rate but saves time. Full Triple Screen discipline produces best results for position/swing trading.
⚠️ Mistake most traders make
Reading about trading is not enough. Traders who practice in real time — tracking signals, analyzing their trades, and learning from results — improve 3x faster. In the Take Profit app, you can do this right away.
Exit Strategy and Position Management
Elder recommends systematic exit framework. (1) Initial stop — 2% of account risk per trade maximum (2% rule). Calculate position size based on stop distance. (2) Profit targets — 2x risk (2R) as minimum target. Some take partial at 2R, trail remainder. (3) Trailing stops — use Parabolic SAR, EMA-based trail (below 22-day EMA for longs), or swing-low trailing. Move stop to breakeven after 1R profit. (4) Reversal exit — if screen one tide reverses (weekly EMA slope flips), exit regardless of profit level. Fighting reversed tide is losing proposition. (5) Oscillator exit — in screen two, when oscillator reaches opposite extreme (from oversold to overbought in long), take partial profit. (6) Re-entry rules — if stopped out, wait for new signal sequence. Don't immediately re-enter without proper setup. Common mistake: revenge trading after small stop-out.
Elder's Money Management rules: (a) 2% rule — never risk more than 2% on single trade. (b) 6% rule — never lose more than 6% of account in single month; if hit, stop trading until next month. This "circuit breaker" prevents catastrophic drawdowns. Mental stops unacceptable — use hard stops in broker. Elder quote: "The goal of successful trading is not to be right but to make money." Exit discipline separates pros from amateurs; system profitable only if exits are systematic.
Adapting Triple Screen to Modern Markets
Triple Screen evolved since 1993 publication. (1) Timeframe flexibility — original weekly/daily/intraday works for swing trading. Day traders adapt: daily/4H/15min. Scalpers: 4H/1H/5min. Maintain 4-5x ratio between screens. (2) Alternative indicators — original uses Elder-Ray, Force Index, MACD. Modern traders use RSI, Stochastic, ATR for same concepts. System is indicator-agnostic; principle matters more than specific tools. (3) Automation — Triple Screen rules easily codify for algorithmic implementation. Popular in systematic trading: daily trend filter + intraday entry trigger. Fewer trades but higher quality than single-timeframe systems. (4) Crypto adaptation — 24/7 markets, apply to crypto: weekly tide + daily trigger + 4H entry for BTC/ETH swing trading. Works despite market immaturity vs forex/stocks. (5) Combining with other methods — Triple Screen compatible with most strategies. Use higher timeframe filter with your existing entry method. Provides trend-alignment discipline to any system.
Elder's 2014 update "The New Trading for a Living" refreshes rules with modern execution tools. Core principles unchanged: trend alignment across timeframes, patience for pullback entries, strict risk management, systematic exits. These principles are timeless; specific indicators and timeframes adapt to trader's style. Despite 30+ years, Triple Screen remains one of the most-referenced retail trading systems, tested and respected by generations of traders.
💡 Most traders read this and... do nothing
Want to see this on a live market?
Reading is 10% of learning. The other 90% is watching a real market. In the Take Profit app, you see how theory works in practice — every day.
- Signals with entry, SL, TP — and the result (73% win rate)
- Trading journal — log every trade and learn from mistakes
- Macro calendar — know when NOT to trade
- AI analysis — understand what the market says today
Related Guides
Multi-Timeframe Analysis
Master multi-timeframe analysis to align your trades with the bigger picture. Learn how to combine higher and lower timeframes for precise, high-probability entries.
Trend Following Strategy
Learn trend following strategy fundamentals. Discover how to identify, enter, and ride market trends using moving averages, breakouts, and momentum tools.
Swing Trading Guide
Master swing trading strategies to capture multi-day price moves. Learn entry timing, trend analysis, and how to hold positions for days or weeks profitably.
Risk Management Basics in Trading
Learn the fundamentals of trading risk management. Discover how to protect your capital with proven rules, position sizing, and disciplined strategies.
Pullback Trading Strategy: Buying Dips in Trends
Master pullback trading — identifying healthy retracements vs reversals, entry triggers at Fibonacci/MA levels, and risk management for trend continuation trades.
→Sound familiar?
•"You enter a trade and instantly regret it"
•"You don't know why the market moved — again"
•"You copy signals but don't understand the reasoning"
•"Trading feels like guessing"
It's not about intelligence — it's about tools. See what trading with structure looks like.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I skip screen three and enter on screen two signals?
Possible but reduces win rate. Screen two signals often occur slightly early, before price confirms direction. Screen three's trailing buy-stop/sell-stop ensures market moves in your favor before entering. Skipping screen three saves time but causes more stop-outs from premature entries. Elder's studies suggest full three-screen approach improves win rate by 5-10% over two-screen method. For swing traders with time, use all three. For part-time traders, two-screen acceptable with slightly larger stops.
Which oscillator is best for screen two?
Elder's preferred: Force Index (2-day EMA), Elder-Ray, MACD histogram, or Stochastic. Stochastic simplest for beginners; provides clear overbought/oversold signals. MACD histogram better for trending markets. Force Index incorporates volume, making it more robust. Choose one and master it; don't flip between tools. Consistency of application matters more than specific indicator. Backtest your choice on historical data to verify edge before live trading.
Does Triple Screen work in crypto?
Yes — Triple Screen adapts well to crypto. Use weekly/daily/4H for swing trading BTC, ETH, major alts. Crypto's trending nature suits screen one's tide concept. Main adaptation: faster market speed may require more frequent re-analysis of weekly tide. Also crypto volatility means wider stops (2-3 ATR) to avoid noise-driven stop-outs. System performed well in 2020-2021 bull market; adapted during 2022 bear market by flipping tide to bearish only in January 2022.
How long between Triple Screen signals?
Typically 1-2 weeks between valid setups per instrument, sometimes longer. All three screens aligning plus screen three entry trigger requires patience. Scan 20-30 instruments regularly to find enough opportunities. Don't force trades during quiet periods — waiting is part of the system. Active traders monitor dozens of markets simultaneously; 3-5 setups per week across broad watchlist is normal. Less trading activity but higher quality is system's trade-off.
Is Triple Screen still relevant after 30+ years?
Absolutely. Core principles — multi-timeframe trend alignment, patience for pullback entries, disciplined stops — are structural market features, not temporary inefficiencies. Specific indicators may be optimized, but the framework remains profitable. Elder's 2014 "The New Trading for a Living" updates rules while preserving essence. Professional trend-followers still use Triple Screen concepts. System's staying power over three decades of evolving markets testifies to fundamental soundness.
Why trust us
Active trader since 2020
Actively trading financial markets since 2020.
Thousands of users
A trusted community of traders using our analysis daily.
Real market analysis
Daily analysis based on data, not guesswork.
Education, not advice
Transparent educational content — you make the decisions.
About the author
Kacper MrukXAUUSD & ETHUSD Trader | Macro + options data | Think, don't follow
Creator of Take Profit Trader's App. Specializes in XAUUSD and ETHUSD, combining macro analysis with options data. He teaches not how to trade, but how to think in the market. Actively trading since 2020.
Related Topics
Before you download — check yourself:
Start free